Hall of Fame

- Induction:
- 2023
- Class:
- 2006
A four-year letterwinner in indoor and outdoor track & field plus cross country, and a two-year captain in all three sports, Scully is a three-time MAC Outdoor Track & Field Most Outstanding Performer after successfully earning crowns in both the 10,000- and 5,000-meter runs. Her four titles over a two-year span earned first-team All-MAC accolades both seasons. Scully also reaped 2005 and 2006 MAC Indoor Track & Field Most Outstanding Performer honors after capturing league championships in the 3,000 and 5,000 both years. She was a recipient of first-team All-MAC honors both seasons in indoor track & field.
Scully is a two-time recipient of All-MAC distinction in cross country. She was runner-up at the 2004 MAC Championship, qualified for the NCAA regional meet, where she finished 10th, and then later competed in the NCAA Championships where she posted a 52nd-place finish. She was runner-up at the 2003 MAC meet, when Ball State captured its first-ever league crown.
Scully qualified for the NCAA Outdoor Track & Field Championships for two straight seasons in the 10,000 meters. She earned a 16th-place finish in the event in 2005. Her career-best time of 33:54.67 was, at the time, the fastest ever by a MAC runner.
She was named to the 2006 ESPN The Magazine Academic All-District V Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Team, as selected by the College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA), and was a three-time Academic All-MAC selection in track and cross country.